Undiagnosed outbreak



Joy Gould looks over her medical file that details her experience with Lyme Disease. Darrell Cole - Amherst Daily News

Joy Gould looks over her medical file that details her experience with Lyme Disease. Darrell Cole - Amherst Daily News

Published on August 29, 2010
Published on August 29, 2010
Darrell Cole  RSS Feed

Amherst residents feels Lyme Disease is under diagnosed

Topics :
Office of Health Promotion and Protection , California , Winnipeg , Port Hawkesbury

AMHERST - Joy Gould believes physicians need to become more aware of Lyme Disease.

The 51-year-old Amherst woman has finally learned she has the disease and may have had it since she was 10.

 

"For nearly four decades I have suffered not only excruciating physical symptoms but have paid socially and emotionally as well," said Gould. "Lyme disease, and the failure to diagnose and treat it, has deprived me of the opportunity to have a healthy family life, a career and the ability to secure a retirement and simply enjoy a good quality of life."

Gould said physicians are not trained to recognize Lyme disease and are often diagnosing it as chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, lupus, Parkinsons disease or some form of mental illness.

Lyme disease is a serious illness spread by the bite of a certain species of ticks.

Because of recurring misdiagnoses and a lack of treatment, Gould said her life has become one of complete disability in that she can no longer work and can no longer do the things many take for granted like go for a long walk.

She was tested several years ago with the results sent to a lab in Winnipeg. She was never told that the test results were indeterminate, meaning they could be positive. She had another test with the results forwarded to a lab in California that uses a different testing process. This time the result came back positive and she's now under the care of a doctor in Port Hawkesbury.

 

The province's deputy chief medical officer would not comment specifically on Gould's case, but said the Office of Health Promotion and Protection has been sending information out to physicians about Lyme disease - as it has for influenza and West Nile Virus.

"Doctors are busy people and it's important we present to them information we believe would be helpful to them from a public health point of view," said Baikie. "They have that information at their fingertips. We send them the tick information because in order for them to make a diagnosis of Lyme it's important they know not only the symptoms but that they take a history of that person."

While Gould is convinced she was exposed to the disease nearly 40 years ago, Baikie is unsure of any diagnoses prior to 2002.

"That's a difficult question to answer. The first case we had reported to us was 2002. We had just started identifying the ticks. I've done a lot of literature review on this and there were a couple of ticks reported before 2001, 2002 but they were from migratory birds," Baikie said. "I can't say how long it's been around and I don't think anyone can."

Baikie feels that now the blacklegged ticks are around they will become more established. For this reason, people need to take precautions when in areas where ticks may be located.

dcole@amherstdaily.com

Comments

  • Username
    Kim
    - March 4, 2011 at 07:19:39

    i am also a lyme desease patient in Canada,i have been seriously ill for over 10 years and was last hospitalised with dementia ,a movement disorder,and cardiac rythm abnormalties-after 10 days in hospital-six of which were spent on a gurny in the ER,i was prononced perfectly healthy after a normal MRI.My husband had to carry me to the car,and i returned home ,obviously gravely ill,to my three kids with no plausible explanation and no medical follow-up.Thank god for a retired MD,Dr.Murakami,who got my blood work to the US and arranged for a local and then PortHawkesbury Doctor to treat my case of late stage lyme and babesiosis.This doc was the only guy in the country brave enough to risk rocking the boat and treat late stage lyme in his clinic.I am from BC,and traveled all the way to Cape Bretton,barely able to stand up,to receive standard recomended treatment i should have had a right to at home.Thank god for his and others help.I now know how lucky i am to have received any care at all.I am still in shock over the inhumane treatment Canadians are receiving at the mercy of our medical athorities- I never thought this could happen in Canada-this denial is totally crazy.We need accountability now.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Abandoned
    - August 30, 2010 at 12:49:08

    In addition to the lack of recognition of Lyme disease in Canada, there is a huge problem with lack of specialists who can diagnose and treat chronic pain and fatigue conditions. There is no clear path or process for primary physicians to follow in order to differentiate one condition from another. Patients are left to fend for themselves, while physicians try to guess where else to send them. There is nobody who is responsible, since everyone claims this type of patient is not their problem. Patients are left undiagnosed for years and even decades.

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      Mae Britton
      - September 2, 2010 at 07:41:02

      Thank you for publishing this important story. I would like to ask Ms. Baikie to respond to my particular situation. Can it please be explained to me why, as a person who had lived in an endemic US region I was denied not only treatment - BUT EVEN TESTING? As I told the doctor repeatedly that the tick biteS had occurred in New York State, a KNOWN endemic region, and as I had a referral in hand from a Infectious Disease Specialist who devoted more than half her practice to treating people suffering with KNOWN and REPEATED tick bites, WHY did the Canadian doctor tell me with no hesitation whatsoever, that there was no reason to consider Lyme disease? This is not a case of denying a Canadian tick bite - it is a case of a Physician discounting irrefutable evidence and medical records! The Canadian Infectious Disease specialist in question told me up front that "he had no experience with Lyme and tick borne diseases" yet REFUSED to defer to the clinically knowlegable US doctor who, with years of experience treating tick borne illness had given me a positive diagnosis (based on test and on CLINICAL presentations, which is after all the way the Centers for Disease Control state this Disease should be diagnosed.) Result: I went to a clinic and got Canadian testing. It was Positive. Conclusion: Canadian doctors are refusing considering testing or diagnosing Lyme EVEN in cases where the patient reports having been bitten OUTSIDE of Canada! This defies logic and disrespects Medical responsibility. QUESTION: where does that leave the ones bitten INSIDE of our borders. (and why are our Borders impermeable to infected migrating ticks??) These questions are NOT rhetorical. They demand some explanation. Thank you for printing this important story.

  • Username
    Dave Bottles
    - August 30, 2010 at 12:38:19

    Darrell: Thanks for your comments concerning Joy. We had to leave B.C. for treatment of Nicole Bottles and go to the States for 8 months. Upon returning, one "health care provider" who wanted to treat Nicole but after checking with the College of Surgeons & Physicians stated - I can not help you for it will jeopardize my career. This statement came with a tone that clearly indicated that this health provider was unset with the decision. What a vile situation we have in Canada!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Debra Fisher
    - August 30, 2010 at 09:36:43

    Thank you so much for printing this story. It is very disheartening, to say the least, to hear the health care professionals saying that this disease has only been reported since 2002 as we know that is the wrong information. Please get on board with the people who are suffering and help us deal with this devasting disease. We haven't even discussed transmission through unprotected sex and also through blood transfusions as was mentioned on a CTV interview in 2008. We need the people who get the information out to the public to get on board and start reporting the correct information. Education is our first line of defense. We need better testing, earlier diagnosis, appropriate treatment from the first stages, as this bacteria is very treatable and curable if caught early. Please help our doctors get the much needed triainging in detecting and treating lymes disease. It is a growing problem and it is not going anywhere.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Elysha T.
    - August 30, 2010 at 07:12:55

    I have a similar history. I believe I contracted Lyme and co-infections when I was 7. I went untreated for 32 years. I was diagnosed by a friend who also has Lyme. If I had not found appropriate treatment, I would not have survived the year. I would have been dead at the age of 42 from Lyme Disease. I am now 3 1/2 years into treatment and regaining my life.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Jim Wilson
    - August 30, 2010 at 07:12:42

    This article is broaching upon a very important matter that needs to be explored. We talk to many people who have been sick for years only to find out it was Lyme, get treated and greatly improve. The deputy chief medical officer Ms. Baikie is not giving the correct facts. The ticks that carry Lyme have been being identified in Nova Scotia for decades as revealed in an access to information search. In fact there is a record of the tick my brother in Port Mouton sent to the government in 1991 that he got off his cat. It was identified as the Ixodes scapularis tick that transmits Lyme disease to humans. There have been many ticks identifed from people who thought to send them in. Can you imagine how many people would not go to the bother of calling the government maze of passing the buck phone lines to finally find where to send a tick in the past 25 years or so? This tells you clearly many more ticks were there then, and like everywhere else in the world their numbers have only increased rapidly. I contracted Lyme disease in 1991 in Dartmouth NS, and had the identifiable bull's eye rash that most people do not get (only 9% according to the latest research) and still it took years of severe illness to have it diagnosed, but now I have my life back after many months of antibiotic treatment. My problem was every time I stopped the antibiotics (felt good on the medication) all my symptoms returned until finally it worked. If our governemt were serious they would fund human pathology to find out how many people with all the neurologial/immune based illnesses like multiple sclerosis, Parkinson's, Lupus, various forms of arthritis, chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia, etc that are collected bankrupting our medical systems. There is leading edge research out there that Canada is falling behind to while we bury our tax dollars into unnecessary expense. The Canadian Lyme Disease Foundation and our experts need to be at the table on every decision made around Lyme disease diagnostics, including in the laboratory, and treatment. We have experts in every field at our fingertips and on our Board. Jim Wilson, President www.canlyme.com

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    C. Pawliuk
    - August 30, 2010 at 07:09:17

    Thank you for printing this story. Lyme disease in Canada has been ignored and denied by government and Infectious Disease specialists for far too long. Too many lives have been ruined because of this denial, including the lives of many innocent children, of which mine is one. It is a horrible unrelenting disease to cope with and most people reach the chronic stage because of lack of proper testing and treatment. Our doctors need more Lyme education and fast because this disease is here to stay.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Madeleine Lapointe
    - August 30, 2010 at 07:08:59

    I've been hearing that same, "we checked the 'literature" for 20 years as I watched my son and daughter deteriorate, even with the costly tests out of country... Doctors in Ontario and Canada only check their own stuff. Anything form Europe etc. is totally ignored. There is a huge amount of data and 'literature' on borreliosis (lyme in North America) going back to the mid 70's. The CDC recognizes 200,000 NEW cases a year all the way to Alaska... quite a miracle that those ticks just don't cross our borders......

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      Lynn Scheuerman
      - September 9, 2010 at 08:08:21

      I have a similar story as those before me. I had a tick under my skin when I was 16. The doctor had no idea what had been on my leg because it had dropped off when I saw one, I found out about lyme from a fellow sufferer when I was 46, so I was diagnoised 31 years after being infected. I have been in treatment now for 3 years and getting better slowly. I am really discusted with the years I have been seeking answers and getting told, fybromyalgia, nothing to be done, See ya! They slam some name on it and walk away. God knows how many other people are infected. I just met a lady diagnoised with MS and she has tested positive for Lyme Disease. She is 44 and had ticks infect her when she was 12. Again, a life of suffering and for what? We truly need change and better treatment here. I have traveled out of province for treatment twice and I am the lucky one because most have to go to the states. This is indeed a sad situation. Thank you for this article, it provides some hope for change in the near future.

Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

This form is NOT used for emailing the article to a friend. Please use the "Send to a friend" link at the top of the page for that purpose.

Cumberland News Now is not responsible for posted comments. Please be polite and confine your comments to the subject of the posted story. If you have an account, please sign on to it..

(we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

loading...
loading...

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising